Monday, March 14, 2011

Atlanta Student Movement Begins with the Publication of "An Appeal for Human Rights," March 14, 1960


On March 14, 1960, Atlantans opened their newspapers to discover "An Appeal for Human Rights," the manifesto that marked the beginning of the Atlanta Student Movement. The Southern Regional Council interviewed many of the participants for its Peabody Award-winning audio series, Will the Circle Be Unbroken, an Audio History of the Civil Rights Movement in Five Southern Communities and the Music of those Times.

Click on the image below to view a video adaptation of portions of the episode of Circle chronicling the events leading up to the publication of the Appeal. Following the image is the full transcript of the episode describing the Atlanta Student Movement.

WILL THE CIRCLE BE UNBROKEN?

A Personal History of the Civil Rights Movement in Five Southern Communities

EPISODE 22: THE ATLANTA STUDENT MOVEMENT

ATLANTA, GEORGIA

Written By: Cliff Kuhn, Steve Suitts and George King with Vertamae Grosvenor

ANDREW YOUNG1

The leaders in that period were not the mayor, not the president; it was four college freshmen that started the sit-in movement, see? It was actually high schools kids who got upset because their parents couldn't register to vote that got the Voting Rights Act, see? And so in all of my lifetime, social change has come from the young while they were in school, see?

SERIES THEME MUSIC: "Will The Circle Be Unbroken?"
[The Staple Singers]

NARRATOR

You are listening to Will The Circle Be Unbroken?, a personal history of the Civil Rights Movement in five southern communities and the music for those times.

During The 1940's And '50's, the Atlanta style emerged as the city's response to racial conflict. Accommodation and compromise guided the approach of the city's leaders-black and white. Warren Cochrane was a member of the small group of ministers, academics, business and professional men who made up Atlanta's black leadership.

WARREN COCHRANE2

Now, we didn't have strength enough or voting power enough to elect anybody in those days. And what we had to do was use whatever strategy we could.

We worked with the business community because they wanted the best leadership we could get, they did not want rabble-rousers. Our job was to keep the rabble-rousers out.

NARRATION

Following the victory of democracy in World War II, and the historic 1954 Supreme Court decision outlawing segregation, no small group of men--- of any color --- could manage the forces of racial change. A new, younger generation would challenge the Atlanta style.

MUSIC
"There Is Something On Your Mind"
[Bobby Marchan]

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

Each college student at that time, especially black college students, brought with them a peculiar kind of history that made everything gel, you know, two or three years later.

JULIAN BOND

There was this accumulation of things that PUSHED on the minds of young people; young black people in 1960.

NARRATOR

Young black American students coming of age at the end of the fifties had grown up in a period of rising expectations. They had witnessed the Montgomery bus boycott on TV, and followed the efforts of Little Rock students in the pages of Jet magazine. In 1960, Julian Bond was a student at Morehouse College in Atlanta.

JULIAN BOND

They had these Little Rock kids who were our peers, and they were so brave and so courageous, that you couldn’t help but say,"Gee, I hope if I’m ever TESTED in this way, I can behave the same way."

Our classmates included African students, who were so smug in their condemnation of our inaction. They’d say, Listen, we’re freeing OUR nations; we’re leading revolutions; we’re escaping the yoke of colonialism. All of Africa will be free before you people can drink a cup of coffee. And you know, that hurt.

NARRATOR

Student Morris Dillard…

MORRIS DILLARD

The pain had reached a point where all you needed was a spark, in the form of a tool—a mechanism through which you could protest. And of course that was provided by the sit-in movement in North Carolina. Greensboro.

MUSIC
"C’mon Everybody"
[Eddie Cochran]

NARRATOR

On February 1, 1960, four black college students startled the nation when they sat in at a segregated lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina. By April, thousands of young people were sitting-in across the south.

JULIAN BOND

It had happened other places before, and they never caught on, they never spread. It may have been that the Associated Press and United Press broadcast fairly neutral descriptions of what was happening. And any newspaper reader could pick that up and say, "Oh, this is how you do it." It’s like an instruction manual.

NARRATOR

Atlanta students took note of this new strategy, where young, committed activists would simply sit-in at segregated facilities—refusing to leave when they were denied service because of their race. Direct and confrontational—as a tactic, it was a radical departure from the Atlanta tradition of quiet compromise and private negotiations.

Morehouse college students Julian Bond and Lonnie King recall how Atlanta’s new era of public protest began.

LONNIE KING

On the second of February 1960 I was talking to one of my best friends at the time a guy named Joseph Pierce. We were reading the paper and I was talking about what happened up in Greensboro.


JULIAN BOND3

I was in Yates and Milton’s Drug Store one day, which was a campus hang-out, killing time between classes, smoking and drinking coffee. And a fellow came up to me, and I didn’t know him well at all. He showed me a newspaper headline from the Atlanta Daily World. It said Greensboro students sit in for third day.

LONNIE KING

I said Julian, you see this newspaper and have you read it?

JULIAN BOND3

He said, Don’t you think it ought to happen here? I said, I’m sure it will.

LONNIE KING

I says, I think we need to make it happen and I’d like to have you help us.

JULIAN BOND3

I said, "What do you mean, we?" He said, "You take this side of the drug store and I’ll take the other side and we’ll put together a little meeting of students."

ACTUALITY: STUDENT MEETING

NARRATOR

At the meeting, the students decided to involve all six of Atlanta’s black colleges in the effort. The college presidents soon got word of things and encouraged the student leaders to draft a list of their grievances.

Student leader Mary Ann Smith…

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

We were very attentive to what the presidents had to say. They said that we would sponsor it, pay for it, you know-you students write it, express your grievances in writing, expose it to the world, well through the Atlanta Journal and Constitution, and we’ll pay for it. And maybe we can initiate some activity this way. Some across-the-table type meetings, negotiations, and what have you.

JULIAN BOND

Well, this very first statement we put in the paper, "the Appeal for Human Rights" listed a LONG list of grievances, police protection; the extension of city services; parks, and things like that. So from the very first, there was this sense that this was about more than lunch counters.

LONNIE KING4

We published it on about the twelfth of March 1960 where we set forward certain things.



JULIAN BOND3

It caused a shock wave to go through the Atlanta community when it was published. Governor Vandiver (who was famous as, No-Not-One-Vandiver "Not-one-black-child-will-ever-enter-a- Georgia-public-school-while-I’m-governor, Vandiver"). Said, This sounds as if it had been written in Moscow, if not in Peking.

GOVERNOR ERNEST VANDIVER8

That statement was skillfully prepared. Obviously, it was not written by students. Regrettably, it had the same overtones which are usually found in anti-American propaganda pieces.

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

Well, all of a sudden you, I won’t say hilarity, but because it was published in the New York Times, I think. New York Times. Letters came in from student governments all over the country.

MUSIC
"Walk Don’t Run"
[The Ventures]

NARRATOR

Atlanta University's college presidents -- part of the older black leadership, were caught in a dilemma. While it was difficult to argue with the students' demands, endorsing them would jeopardize the Atlanta style of private negotiation and threaten the power of the older leaders in the community.

Lonnie King...

LONNIE KING3

They saw themselves being replaced. That I think caused a great deal of problem. You had the old guard black leadership who were upset about these young upstarts who were coming in here. For that many to make gains in a year or less that they had been working on as they saw it for 30 or 40 years. Then, of course, the whites who were in power didn't want to give up anything without you just taking it from them.

NARRATOR

But the students would not be quieted, and they had their own sense of style.

JULIAN BOND

Part of what we wanted to do was to demonstrate that Atlanta students were going to be the best organized; the most disciplined; because this was then the largest collection of black college students in America.

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

Each student leader from the various campuses would go and sort of pick students that would go to represent your college, who wanted to participate. That's the way the first one was done.

JULIAN BOND

We wanted to be the best. And surpass whatever had been done before, and whatever would be done afterward. So we wanted to hit the maximum number of places with the maximum number of people.

NARRATOR

Two of the groups at Atlanta's first sit-in demonstration were led by Julian Bond and fellow Morehouse student Charles Black.

CHARLES BLACK5

We had cased all the joints you might say. We knew exactly how many seats there were in every place; we knew where the nearest telephones were; we knew where to put observers so they could see everything that was going on and relay messages; the whole works—we had planned it very carefully.

JULIAN BOND

200 students went all over Atlanta; different groups to different places...I took a group of people down to the City Hall cafeteria.

NARRATOR

Again, Charles Black...

CHARLES BLACK

The group that I led was at the Terminal Train Station. The city leadership was taken quite by surprise. They didn't know what to do. There were lots of reports of policemen turning around in the middle of the street in their cars. After getting the call from one place and then another, they were just spinning around, not knowing what to do.

NARRATOR

Despite the publication of the Appeal for Human Rights and sit-ins in other cities across the South, the students' occupation of ten different segregated public facilities took Atlanta by surprise. When the confusion abated, most of the students were arrested and taken to jail.

JULIAN BOND

And we were all convicted and bound over to the grand jury, and bonded out, and came back to Paschal's Restaurant for a celebratory chicken dinner. We were all heroes and heroines.

MUSIC
"You Better Leave Segregation Alone"
[James Bevel, Joseph Carter, Bernard Lafayette, Samuel Collier]

NARRATOR

Atlanta's older black leadership was divided. Most felt that the students' radical tactics would jeopardize their own patient work to desegregate Atlanta. But some worked along with the students; black business leader Jesse Hill...

JESSE HILL

My job was, to get them out of jail, I really did, I was pretty busy, I had quite a team...I had black professionals, doctors, lawyers, school teachers who gave me there properties...We had funds, we had bonding capacity. We were equipped. We were ready for war.

JULIAN BOND

We got out of jail because black business people here put up their property and their cash to get us out. So their immediate response was supportive and helpful. But their second response was, Gee, that's great that you've done this thing. And now that you've done it, you don't have to do it again. Let us handle it. We can deal with it. We have relationships with the White power people downtown; let black power and White power get together and work this out. That's the way we've always done it, and that's the way we'll do it now.

LONNIE KING

The people who were in the leadership at that time were unelected.

CHARLES BLACK5

They didn't think that Atlanta was such a bad place for them. They had always had pretty good relations with the white folk. They had always put their few votes with the Northside white vote to elect fairly decent city officials, they thought.

JULIAN BOND

And I think some of us were willing to say, well, that's great, "you know, you can do it." And others said, "No, we've been depending on you to do this all this time. You haven't done it with the rapidity and speed that we insist it be done. So we're gonna have to take this into our hands again, and go for it and do something else."

NARRATOR

Again, student Morris Dillard...

MORRIS DILLARD

We created the infrastructure that was required to support a movement of this sort.

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

Hectic, that's all I remember, telephones ringing and getting flyers for the next meeting and seeing who's going to speak, setting up the program.

MORRIS DILLARD

Housewives drove carpools and they had food and they did all kinds of things that were necessary to keep the operation running.

MARY ANN SMITH WILSON

And I just didn't realize until it was all over just how totally involved I was, but that was my life for several months.

MORRIS DILLARD

It wasn't a one-time shot and that's what Lonnie was telling us early on is that you've got to be prepared to stay. You can't think that just by mounting a big march downtown that the walls of segregation are gonna come down. No.

LONNIE KING3

And then we began the movement. It was out there. The lines were drawn.

MUSIC
"This Magic Moment"
[The Drifters]

NARRATOR

That fall the students moved their organizing off the campuses and against the private sector.

Rich's, Atlanta's leading department store, although still strictly segregated, was known for treating black customers relatively well.

Lucy Grigsby...

I'm sure more blacks had credit cards at Rich's and more blacks went to Rich's than went to other stores because they felt more comfortable there.

ARCHIVAL RICH'S8

Rich's is a personal store. And our success this year and next year and the next will depend so much on how well we all know what we stand for and how well we practice our beliefs.

JULIAN BOND3

There was a saying at least we knew in Atlanta that if Rich's went, so would everybody else. If Rich's decided to sell green shoes at Christmas time, everybody else would sell green shoes at Christmas time too.

NARRATOR

And so Rich's Department Store became a symbolic target for the demonstrators.

Lonnie King...

LONNIE KING4

I remember once I sat in Rich's and they closed down the counter. So then I got a call from the police chief. He asked me to come down there. He sent a patrol car down there to get me from our office on Auburn Avenue at that time.

JULIAN BOND

Chief Jenkins had his men pick up the leaders of the student movement, Lonnie King and Herschelle Sullivan, and take them to a meeting at the police station with Richard Rich, the head of Rich's department store.

LONNIE KING

Mr. Rich, he was extremely arrogant, extremely upset with me for quote, "disrupting commerce in his store." And he, he didn't want to hear anything I had to say. He wanted to give me a lecture. And his lecture was, that if you come back to Rich's Department Store again, I'm going to put you in jail.

JULIAN BOND

And Mr. Rich said something he NEVER should have said. He lost his temper. He said, "I don't care if another Negro EVER comes into my store." And he NEVER should have said that, because within a year, we made sure that Negroes DID NOT go in his store, and ran this boycott that eventually resulted in the integration of the Atlanta restaurants, lunch counters and so on.

ARCHIVAL TV AD: RICH'S8

Without people Rich's is just another store full of merchandise. Without people our policies are just so many theories.

NARRATOR

Black Atlanta was united behind the student-led boycott. People from different generations and occupations joined the picket lines.

Charles Black...

CHARLES BLACK

Well after it was clear that the students had the support generally of the community, everybody wanted to walk then, all the preachers, all the everybody. And the folk who had done everything they could to stop it were out there marching, young and old.

NARRATOR

Julia Bond, mother of student Julian...


And they just didn't see how they could do without Rich's, but they joined the boycott. Afterwards, so many people who had gone to Rich's and spent so much money learned that it really wasn't necessary. They could do without some of those things.

CLARENCE BACOTE2

My wife was one of those who participated in the boycott. Of course, I must say I was a little selfish then. I didn't care how long they were parading around Rich's. It was saving me money!

LONNIE KING

We got these people in Atlanta, Georgia to send us their Rich's charge cards. And we put them in safety deposit boxes at Rich's. Our slogan was, "Close down your account with segregation, open up your account with freedom, send us your charge card."

MUSIC
"Shop Around"
[Smokey Robinson and The Miracles]

NARRATOR

As the boycott moved into the spring of 1961, Atlanta's white power structure and the older black leadership continued to negotiate. They focused on persuading the students to drop their demands until the city's potentially volatile school desegregation plan took place in the fall of 1961. At a transformative meeting they achieved their goal.

Lonnie King...

LONNIE KING3

It was an extremely emotional meeting, one in which I found people who were supposed to have been on my side, siding with the merchants. It was a very excruciating feeling.

NARRATOR

Mayor Ivan Allen and the city's white business leadership leaned on the older black leaders who in turn pressured student leader Lonnie King to accept the compromise.

LUCY GRIGSBY3

I'm sure more blacks had credit cards at Rich's and more blacks went to Rich's than went to other stores because they felt more comfortable there.

ARCHIVAL RICH'S8

Rich's is a personal store. And our success this year and next year and the next will depend so much on how well we all know what we stand for and how well we practice our beliefs.

JULIAN BOND3

There was a saying at least we knew in Atlanta that if Rich's went, so would everybody else. If Rich's decided to sell green shoes at Christmas time, everybody else would sell green shoes at Christmas time too.

NARRATOR

And so Rich's Department Store became a symbolic target for the demonstrators.

Lonnie King...

LONNIE KING4

I remember once I sat in Rich's and they closed down the counter. So then I got a call from the police chief. He asked me to come down there. He sent a patrol car down there to get me from our office on Auburn Avenue at that time.

JULIAN BOND

Chief Jenkins had his men pick up the leaders of the student movement, Lonnie King and Herschelle Sullivan, and take them to a meeting at the police station with Richard Rich, the head of Rich's department store.

LONNIE KING

Mr. Rich, he was extremely arrogant, extremely upset with me for quote, "disrupting commerce in his store." And he, he didn't want to hear anything I had to say. He wanted to give me a lecture. And his lecture was, that if you come back to Rich's Department Store again, I'm going to put you in jail.

JULIAN BOND

And Mr. Rich said something he NEVER should have said. He lost his temper. He said, "I don't care if another Negro EVER comes into my store." And he NEVER should have said that, because within a year, we made sure that Negroes DID NOT go in his store, and ran this boycott that eventually resulted in the integration of the Atlanta restaurants, lunch counters and so on.

ARCHIVAL TV AD: RICH'S8

Without people Rich's is just another store full of merchandise. Without people our policies are just so many theories.

NARRATOR

Black Atlanta was united behind the student-led boycott. People from different generations and occupations joined the picket lines.

Charles Black...

CHARLES BLACK

Well after it was clear that the students had the support generally of the community, everybody wanted to walk then, all the preachers, all the everybody. And the folk who had done everything they could to stop it were out there marching, young and old.

LONNIE KING4

Anyway, I capitulated. As I look back in retrospect, that was probably one of the major decisions that I made that I'm ashamed of.

NARRATOR

Activist Benjamin Brown...

BENJAMIN BROWN7

Some of the students felt that Lonnie King, our head, our chairman, had sold them out. And they requested his resignation. So that was one of those real emotional moments in the whole movement. People crying and carrying on, you know.

LONNIE KING4

To wrap it all up, Ivan Allen went on television this same night and said that the lunch counters will open up again tomorrow; segregated. The Negroes have agreed to wait and time it with the opening of schools...It became very clear that his job was to try and work out an agreement whereby from a PR point of view, it would appear as if the white folks gave us something as opposed to black folks winning something. You follow me?

NARRATOR

As word got out about the decision to call off the boycott in return for desegregated facilities in the fall, a mass meeting was arranged. Atlanta University professor Carl Holman and attorney Leroy Johnson remember the evening.

CARL HOLMAN3

And we'd had this big meeting at Warren Methodist Church at which point the black negotiators found how deep the feeling was about having been betrayed. And we had to go through that evening with the hope that we would keep the black community from tearing itself apart.

LEROY JOHNSON II

And the church was packed. And the students were there looking for blood. And we were sitting on the platform, nervous, trying to make certain that we could appease the crowd in the sense of trying to get them to accept the agreement and they were saying, no, no, no and all hell broke loose.

MUSIC

LONNIE KING3

Oh, man. That meeting.... About 2,000 people had gathered. An array of leaders tried to calm the crowd. And so Martin King's father got up, King, Sr., and he attempted to get them to calm down. He said that he devoted 30 years of his life to the Civil Rights Movement in Atlanta and before he could go any further, this lady up in the stands said, "And that's what's wrong." And she proceeded to come down and she read the riot act to everybody there.

JULIAN BOND1

I can remember this nurse, she was in her uniform, she was a nurse for Dr.

Albert Davis, storming up the center of the church, saying, "You mean to tell me, you know, I tore up my credit card." [LAUGHTER]

Some of the students felt that Lonnie King, our head, our chairman, had sold them out. And they requested his resignation. So that was one of those real emotional moments in the whole movement. People crying and carrying on, you know.

LONNIE KING

Oh, God, the church went up. I mean you've seen these magical moments. The church went up. I mean they just, it was something. I felt sorry for King, because King had laid the groundwork in a lot of ways, but remember now these people are operating on incremental change. And all of a sudden here's revolutionary change.

Martin King by that time had eased in the back, Jr. And when they booed his daddy, he started crying. Tears started coming down...So finally, Martin said, "Let me talk."

MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.8

We must honestly say to Atlanta that time is running out. If some concrete changes for good are not made soon, Negro leaders of this city will find it impossible to convince the masses of Negroes of good faith of the negotiations presently taking place.

LEROY JOHNSON II

Martin Luther King, Jr. came to the meeting and spoke to that crowd and he said in essence that this agreement may not be all that we want, but it's an agreement we made and I think we ought to accept it. And shift the burden to the white folks and let them break it. But his speech was so terrific and I never thought anybody could have quelled that crowd.

LONNIE KING3

I've never heard a speech like that before or since. His march on Washington speech was nothing compared to that speech that night.

MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.8

Atlanta needs an Amos to cry out, let justice roll down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream. Atlanta needs another Jefferson to scratch across the pages of history words lifted to cosmic proportions: We hold these truths to be self evident that all men are created equal.

LEROY JOHNSON II

He stopped that crowd and the students then agreed to accept the agreement and that's what happened. But for Martin Luther King it never would have been accepted.

NARRATOR

In the fall of 1961, Rich's Department Store and some other facilities, including the public schools, began to desegregate with a token number of blacks. Although the coalition of students and community members held together, the power of the older black leadership was broken. The new direct action tactics continued through the mid-sixties forcing desegregation into the open. As new leadership emerged, they too would discover the challenges of power—as the Atlanta style proved resilient once again.

MUSIC
"Giant Steps"
[John Coltrane]


CREDITS


Key to Archival Collections
1
Highlander Folk School Collection, Highlander Research and Education Center, New Market, TN
2
WRFG-FM/"Living Atlanta," Collection, courtesy of Atlanta History Center, Atlanta, GA
3
"Dawn’s Early Light," Ralph McGill Papers, Woodruff Library, Emory University, Atlanta, GA
4
Oral History Collection of Martin Luther King, Jr., license granted by Intellectual Properties Management, Atlanta, GA
5
Howard University, Ralphe J. Bunche Oral History Collection, Washington, DC
6
Atlanta-Fulton County Public Library, Special Collections, Atlanta, GA
7
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Southern Historical Collection & Southern Folklife Collection, Wilson Library, Chapel Hill, NC
8
WSB Television News Video Archive, University of Georgia, Athens, GA

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Atlanta's Continuing Struggle for a More Representative Federal Bench


Imagine a time when all of the full-time judges on Atlanta's federal district court are white; when circumstances have conspired to create a number of vacancies on the court; when, even in those circumstances, it's far from clear that the court's all-white composition will change any time soon and, if it's going to change, it's far from clear that any new judge will have the demonstrated qualities of empathy and compassion which are all too rare; when it becomes necessary for people of good will to mobilize to assure that the selection process produces a bench that is more qualified and more representative.

The time to which I refer could easily be 2010 or early 2011, but it's not. Rather, I refer to 1978.

Congress had just passed the Omnibus Judgeship Bill, creating scores of new judgeships around the country. In the Northern District of Alabama, two African American judges were appointed under the bill. In the Northern District of Georgia - which had just as many open judgeships - it would be a struggle to get even one African American judge.

Fortunately, out of all the candidates under consideration in Georgia's Northern District, there was one candidate who had that rare combination of qualities around which people of good will could unite. He had been valedictorian of his graduating class at East Depot High School in LaGrange, Georgia; an honors graduate of Morehouse College, and the recipient of a Masters from Atlanta University and a law degree from Northwestern. He had been the first plaintiff to challenge segregation at the University of Georgia, and he had been part of the team that finally brought that segregation to an end - the same team that also brought an end to the all-white jury pools that existed in some Georgia counties. He had been the second African American to be elected to the Georgia Senate since Reconstruction; the first African American to serve on what was then called the Civil Court of Fulton County; and the first African American to serve on the Superior Court of Fulton County. He was known to agonize over sentencing decisions and, among all of his colleagues on the Fulton Superior Court, he had the lowest reversal rate.

With a good bit of effort on the part of people of good will (including a President with whom he had served in the Georgia Senate, including a Senator who had blocked his admission to the University of Georgia, and including people of good will from across the community and across the nation), this candidate in 1979 was appointed to the court, where his many cases ironically included the Jan Kemp case involving free speech at the University of Georgia and where, today, as a Senior Judge, he continues to serve with distinction.

The person to whom I refer is Horace T. Ward.

Today, Judge Ward is a member of the Halls of Fame of the Gate City Bar and the National Bar. He has received the Distinguished Alumni Award from Atlanta University; the Bennie Service Award from Morehouse College; the Merit Award from Northwestern University; the Trumpet Award for Civil Rights Advocacy from Turner Broadcasting System. Atlanta Magazine summed up his career in 1976 when it recognized him as one of 200 people who shaped Atlanta.

In 1978 the appointment of Judge Ward - or any person of color, for that matter - was far from being a foregone conclusion. Even with his impeccable background, his appointment required concerted action on the part of a broad coalition of people who cared about a more representative judiciary.

And so it is today.

As this year began, there were four vacant positions on Atlanta's federal district court and no full-time African American judges. On February 28, the Senate voted to confirm two new judges on that court, including one African American who resides in another federal district. Even with these appointments, however, the court has no judges of color who actually reside in the district.

The President has moved to remedy this situation, nominating two African American candidates for the two remaining vacancies, both of whom actually reside in the district. If these nominations are confirmed, the court will also have its first Black female judges.

These latest nominations are a positive development. But a nomination doesn't always result in a confirmation, especially in a State which has no Senators who belong to the President's party. Just as in 1978, if Atlanta is going to achieve the goal of having a quality federal court which is also truly representative, it will be necessary for people of good will to come together to make it happen.